Sentencing policy rarely makes for easy reading and the current period of reform is no exception. The Sentencing Bill 2025, introduced to Parliament in September 2025 and still working its way through its legislative stages, represents one of the most significant overhauls of sentencing law in England and Wales for a generation. For those working with older people in the criminal justice system, it raises a number of important questions, not all of which have clear answers yet.

Why reform is happening now
England and Wales face a prison population close to record highs and capacity near breaking point. Without reform, demand is projected to exceed supply by 9,500 places by early 2028.
In response, the Government commissioned an Independent Sentencing Review, led by former Lord Chancellor David Gauke. The review concluded that the current trajectory, characterised by longer sentences and an over-reliance on custody, is fiscally unsustainable and ineffective in reducing reoffending.
The Sentencing Bill seeks to reduce reliance on short custodial sentences and expand community-based alternatives. Under the Bill, prisoners must serve at least 33% of their term before release, or 50% for serious crimes, and early release is earned rather than guaranteed, dependent on good behaviour and engagement with rehabilitation programmes.
What the review says about older people
One of the more notable aspects of the Gauke review is that it explicitly recognises older people as a distinct group within the prison population. For practitioners working with older people in custody, one of the more notable aspects of the review is the explicit recognition of older people as a distinct group requiring targeted intervention.
Compassionate release has long been available in principle, but rarely used in practice. Many older people with serious health conditions remain in custody despite being eligible, in part because the bar for release is high and the process is complex. An expansion of this provision, if it translates into meaningful practice, could have a real impact on the older people Recoop works with.
The limits of reform for this group
The reforms are not straightforwardly positive for all older people in custody. Many older people are serving long or complex sentences, including extended and indeterminate sentences, meaning they may see limited direct benefit from reforms focused on earlier release or shorter custodial terms. Some offence categories will remain outside aspects of the reform framework, further limiting impact for parts of the older prison population.
“The growing recognition of older people within sentencing discussions is an important step forward. But policy reform alone will not change outcomes. Practitioners working across prisons, probation and the voluntary sector understand that older people often face complex health, housing and social care needs that require coordinated support. The question is not simply who becomes eligible for release, but whether the right support is in place when they get there.”
Paul Grainge Recoop CEO
The earned progression model
For those who are eligible, the shift to an earned progression model introduces both opportunity and risk. The principle, that earlier release should be linked to behaviour and engagement, has some logic to it. In practice, however, older people in custody may face particular challenges in demonstrating progress in ways that the system recognises.
Engagement with rehabilitation programmes is one of the factors likely to influence progression decisions, yet many programmes are not designed with older people in mind. Physical or cognitive limitations can act as barriers to participation. If earned progression relies heavily on programme completion, older people in custody who cannot access those programmes risk being disadvantaged through no fault of their own.

What this means for resettlement
The shift toward community sentences has raised concerns that, while the measures might ease pressure on the prison estate, they will create significant new demands on an already stretched probation service.
For older people, the adequacy of community provision is a serious concern. Release into the community is only beneficial if the right support is in place: housing, healthcare and social connection. These are precisely the areas where older people leaving custody are most vulnerable. Reform of sentencing without parallel investment in resettlement and community support risks creating a different set of problems further down the line.
What Recoop’s position is
Recoop welcomes any serious engagement with the distinct needs of older people in the criminal justice system at the level of national policy. The explicit recognition of older offenders as a group requiring targeted intervention is significant and should be built upon.
Reform at the level of sentencing law will, however, only go so far. The daily experience of older people in custody and the risks they face on release, will continue to require consistent, practical support from organisations like Recoop, whatever the legislative framework looks like.
“The growing recognition of older people within sentencing discussions is an important step forward. But policy reform alone will not change outcomes. Practitioners working across prisons, probation and the voluntary sector understand that older people often face complex health, housing and social care needs that require coordinated support. The question is not simply who becomes eligible for release, but whether the right support is in place when they get there.”















